19 Harley St, London, W1G 9QJ, UK

Surgeons agree to disagree on surgical options for degenerative conditions of the cervical and lumbar spine

STUDY DESIGN: This is a survey study designed to evaluate agreement among spine surgeons regarding treatment options for six clinical scenarios involving degenerative conditions of the cervical and lumbar spine. OBJECTIVES: The purpose was to evaluate whether or not surgeons agree on which cases require operative intervention and what type of surgery should be performed. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Agreement between spine surgeons on when to operate and what procedure to perform is a subject that has received increasing attention. This is an important question in the field of spine surgery, where ‘gold standards’ that are based on large clinical trials are relatively sparse. METHODS: Six clinical vignettes were presented to 19 members of the Degenerative Spine Study Group. Each vignette was accompanied by a series of radiographs and/or magnetic resonance imagings, followed by treatment options in multiple-choice format. Two months later, the same vignettes were sent out with identical instructions except that they were now told they were treating a close family member. RESULTS: More than 76% of surgeons agreed on whether or not to recommend surgical intervention for the following four cases: lumbar degenerative spondylolisthesis with stenosis, cervical herniated nucleus pulposus, lumbar spondylosis, and lumbar herniated nucleus pulposus. Two scenarios had approximately 50% surgeon agreement: cervical stenosis and lumbar spondylolysis. However, despite good inter-rater agreement about who needed surgery, there was poor agreement regarding what procedure to perform if surgery was recommended. When repeating the survey in the setting of operating on a family member, only 17 (17.7%) of 96 recommendations were changed. CONCLUSION: Spine surgeons in this survey generally agreed on when to operate but failed to agree on what type of procedures to perform

Keywords : Cervical Vertebrae,Data Collection,Humans,Lumbar Vertebrae,Magnetic Resonance Imaging,methods,Neurodegenerative Diseases,Orthopedic Procedures,pathology,Physicians,Spinal Diseases,Spine,Spondylolisthesis,Spondylolysis,Spondylosis,statistics & numerical data,surgery,Universities,, Agree,Disagree,Surgical, bearable pain

Date of Publication : 2011 Feb 1

Authors : Lee JY;Hohl JB;Fedorka CJ;Devin C;Brodke DS;Branch CL;Vaccaro AR;

Organisation : Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA. joonyunglee@hotmail.com

Journal of Publication : Spine (Phila Pa 1976 )

Pubmed Link : https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21192301

The London Spine Unit : Harley Street UK. Specialists in Cutting Edge Technologies for Spinal Surgery

Make an Appointment 

Trustpilot Reviews
Doctify Reviews
Top Doctor Reviews

Surgeons agree to disagree on surgical options for degenerative conditions of the cervical and lumbar spine | Ultrasound clinic london

What our patients say ...

Consultant Spine Surgeon
Consultant Spine Surgeon
Consultant Spine Surgeon

This surgical technique consists of a percutaneous approach for the treatment of small to medium size hernias of the intervertebral disc by laser energy. The main objective is to reduce the intradiscal pressure in the nucleus pulposus

Laser Disc Surgery can be performed under local anaesthetic as a day case at our centre on the prestigious Harley Street.
What is London spine unit and How it Works

The London Spine Unit was established in 2005 and has successfully treated over 5000 patients. All conditions are treated.

treatment of all spinal disorders

The London Spine Unit specialises in Minimally Invasive Treatments allowing rapid recovery and return to normal function

Trusted by patients worldwide

The London Spine Unit provides the highest quality care to all patients and has VIP services for those seeking exceptional services

If you have any emergency Doctor’s need, simply call our 24 hour emergency

Your personal case manager will ensure that you receive the best possible care.

Call Now 

+44 844 589 2020
+44 203 973 8810